Dubai Telegraph - Gone in 30 years? The Welsh village in crosshairs of climate change

EUR -
AED 4.225652
AFN 74.781422
ALL 93.172811
AMD 421.052567
AOA 1054.989049
ARS 1719.121524
AUD 1.645162
AWG 2.073739
AZN 1.966712
BAM 1.952625
BBD 2.316801
BDT 142.037287
BHD 0.433844
BIF 3445.684793
BMD 1.150479
BND 1.475205
BOB 14.004252
BRL 5.872623
BSD 1.150259
BTN 109.610603
BWP 15.644674
BYN 3.362513
BYR 22549.38963
BZD 2.313477
CAD 1.616521
CDF 2602.383819
CHF 0.933234
CLF 0.026952
CLP 1064.251123
CNY 7.768725
CNH 7.775841
COP 3730.370837
CRC 522.516208
CUC 1.150479
CUP 30.487695
CVE 110.733442
CZK 24.214474
DJF 204.463134
DKK 7.476256
DOP 67.015623
DZD 153.007976
EGP 57.663627
ERN 17.257186
ETB 184.018741
FJD 2.552112
FKP 0.853363
GBP 0.857308
GEL 3.003154
GGP 0.853363
GHS 13.4721
GIP 0.853363
GMD 85.135506
GNF 10066.691947
GTQ 8.776194
GYD 241.031269
HKD 9.022224
HNL 30.831984
HRK 7.535344
HTG 150.395619
HUF 364.449882
IDR 20694.817381
ILS 3.501638
IMP 0.853363
INR 109.654226
IQD 1507.127572
IRR 1582196.33128
ISK 142.015652
JEP 0.853363
JMD 182.213385
JOD 0.815707
JPY 180.642471
KES 148.791673
KGS 100.609628
KHR 4645.047021
KMF 492.405068
KRW 1645.311841
KWD 0.356071
KYD 0.958587
KZT 545.649452
LAK 26000.827293
LBP 103025.400201
LKR 386.210115
LRD 208.524101
LSL 19.017405
LTL 3.397066
LVL 0.695913
LYD 7.322825
MAD 10.739434
MDL 20.084204
MGA 4899.755071
MKD 61.416653
MMK 2415.641494
MNT 4134.279366
MOP 9.291565
MRU 46.122794
MUR 53.795901
MVR 17.775066
MWK 1998.382168
MXN 19.949934
MYR 4.711789
MZN 73.518466
NAD 19.0174
NGN 1569.161798
NIO 42.327671
NOK 10.991775
NPR 175.378125
NZD 1.962585
OMR 0.442347
PAB 1.150249
PEN 3.905298
PGK 5.076458
PHP 70.072799
PKR 319.631884
PLN 4.314383
PYG 6861.424306
QAR 4.194359
RON 5.247219
RSD 117.37763
RUB 92.498091
RWF 1688.903264
SAR 4.305701
SBD 9.297142
SCR 15.579762
SDG 690.287687
SEK 11.014508
SGD 1.476323
SLE 28.12944
SOS 657.390936
SRD 43.495
STD 23812.593791
STN 24.458736
SVC 10.064801
SZL 19.017571
THB 38.471631
TJS 10.622786
TMT 4.026677
TND 3.382985
TRY 54.678932
TTD 7.799807
TWD 37.364799
TZS 3043.321989
UAH 51.597975
UGX 4304.756289
USD 1.150479
UYU 46.262154
UZS 13821.855768
VES 860.387379
VND 30242.643122
VUV 136.964711
WST 3.145975
XAF 654.855061
XAG 0.01993
XAU 0.000285
XCD 3.109228
XCG 2.073103
XDR 0.813195
XOF 656.350485
XPF 119.331742
YER 274.271757
ZAR 19.037552
ZMK 10355.697109
ZMW 21.617342
ZWL 370.453789
  • BCC

    6.5000

    82.88

    +7.84%

  • CMSC

    -0.0800

    21.76

    -0.37%

  • GSK

    -0.1800

    51.51

    -0.35%

  • RBGPF

    -3.2100

    66

    -4.86%

  • BCE

    0.0800

    21.76

    +0.37%

  • RIO

    -0.9300

    95.92

    -0.97%

  • JRI

    -0.1400

    12.82

    -1.09%

  • BTI

    -1.0850

    59.565

    -1.82%

  • RELX

    0.7350

    36.155

    +2.03%

  • NGG

    -0.1100

    79.86

    -0.14%

  • RYCEF

    0.8000

    20.3

    +3.94%

  • VOD

    -0.1700

    15.61

    -1.09%

  • AZN

    -11.6750

    157.965

    -7.39%

  • BP

    -1.0000

    44.22

    -2.26%

  • CMSD

    -0.0400

    22.07

    -0.18%

Gone in 30 years? The Welsh village in crosshairs of climate change
Gone in 30 years? The Welsh village in crosshairs of climate change / Photo: Paul ELLIS - AFP

Gone in 30 years? The Welsh village in crosshairs of climate change

Occasionally at night, if the weather's bad when she walks her dog along the waterfront, Georgina Salt admits feeling a little "frisson" at the vulnerability of her exposed Welsh village.

Text size:

Otherwise, like many residents in Fairbourne, northwest Wales, she tries not to worry that rising sea levels are predicted to swamp the village.

A decade ago, Fairbourne -- in a stunning but perilous position sandwiched between the Irish Sea, an estuary and the mountains of Snowdonia National Park -- was given an official death sentence.

But Salt, a community councillor, thinks the decision by local authority Gwynedd Council and others to relocate Fairbourne by the mid-2050s was made prematurely, without adequate consideration or consultation -- and could now itself be abandoned.

"The biggest problem was they put a date on things," she told AFP in the condemned village.

"We're trying to get them (the council) to... be a bit more flexible about it and say, 'we're going to keep an eye on things'."

After a summer of drought and record temperatures, the UK is increasingly bracing for the many varied impacts of human-caused climate change while this week saw a US government report emerge showing the planet's sea levels rising for a 10th straight year.

Meteorologists noted last month that the seas surrounding the UK are rising at a far faster rate than a century ago, while the head of the Environment Agency warned in June that some coastal communities "cannot stay where they are".

- 'Catastrophic' -

But Fairbourne, founded in the late 1880s by a Victorian flour merchant and now home to up to 900 people, could be considered a cautionary tale of how to proceed.

In 2013, Gwynedd Council adopted proposals in the region's latest Shoreline Management Plan (SMP) to stop maintaining the village's flood defences and relocate its residents in 40 to 50 years.

The following year, the devolved Welsh Assembly in Cardiff, which has powers over environmental policy, also signed off on the SMP, which said Fairbourne faced long-term "catastrophic flood risk".

A subsequent multi-agency "masterplan" proposed decommissioning the village "by 2054".

SMPs have been conducted for the entire UK coastline in recent decades but Fairbourne appears to be the first place given that fate, despite not flooding severely in generations.

Residents say the order quickly "blighted" the village. They were labelled Britain's first "climate refugees" in a flurry of media attention.

With prospective home buyers unable to get mortgages, sales dried up and property values fell by nearly half.

Meanwhile, Gwynedd Council has faced persistent criticism for failing to detail its relocation plans, with frustrated locals left feeling they were unfairly singled out.

- 'Death... by supposition' -

"We weren't told where we were going to live... how people with jobs will find new jobs," said retiree Angela Thomas.

Locals are living under a "sword of Damocles", unsure whether to spend money on their homes or even on a holiday, she added.

"Some people may be thinking, 'Crikey, I've got to leave that money in the bank just in case I'm turfed out of my home'."

Residents note other more flood-prone places, such as Barmouth on the other side of the estuary, have not had the same treatment.

"There's many villages... around the coast of Great Britain that will also be in the same predicament," said Stuart Eves, another local councillor who also runs a campsite.

"You can't condemn a village 40 years into the future and not have... any form of plan in place," he added, sitting off the main street near the sole pub, post office, grocery store and railway station.

"(It's) the ultimate death of a village by supposition."

Some even sense a conspiracy given that Fairbourne, which sits in a predominantly Welsh-speaking part of Wales, hosts many retirees from England.

"We had even Welsh residents coming back to us saying 'I do sometimes think that we're being targeted because it's a mainly English community'," said Salt.

- 'Don't agree' -

After nearly a decade of recriminations, locals say the devolved Welsh Assembly is reassessing the SMP and 2054 decision.

External consultants have been chosen to review the latest evidence, residents claim -- though the Welsh government has not confirmed as much.

That includes a report by a local academic with relevant expertise which argues the SMP ignored the dynamism of Fairbourne's natural shingle bank beach, as well as the cost of decommissioning and returning the village to marshland.

A spokesman for the Labour-led government in Cardiff declined to confirm that a review was underway but said Gwynedd Council's decision "does not necessarily mean that funding will end in 2054" for flood defences.

Natural Resources Wales, the government agency which maintains sea defences, conceded that protecting Fairbourne was "working against nature".

"As long as funding is available, we will continue to monitor and maintain the village's flood defences to protect the community of Fairbourne," a spokesperson added.

Gwynedd Council declined to comment.

In the meantime, the village appears to be recovering from the earlier fallout. Some property sales are now happening and new residents arriving.

"I can't see it (relocation) happening," said one of them, 23-year-old Mike Owen.

He recently moved with his parents and girlfriend from northwest England, drawn by the area's relative affordability and natural beauty.

"I don't agree with it -- why would you give up on something?"

H.Sasidharan--DT