Dubai Telegraph - Six young people sue 32 European states over climate change

EUR -
AED 4.276911
AFN 77.00261
ALL 96.561039
AMD 444.455439
ANG 2.084659
AOA 1067.918724
ARS 1670.580382
AUD 1.753592
AWG 2.099152
AZN 1.98201
BAM 1.955612
BBD 2.346285
BDT 142.406334
BGN 1.956282
BHD 0.439022
BIF 3441.169761
BMD 1.164578
BND 1.510655
BOB 8.078225
BRL 6.329131
BSD 1.164893
BTN 104.857487
BWP 15.497513
BYN 3.368991
BYR 22825.733483
BZD 2.342885
CAD 1.612865
CDF 2599.338258
CHF 0.937992
CLF 0.027397
CLP 1074.765709
CNY 8.235549
CNH 8.227437
COP 4451.018029
CRC 568.84541
CUC 1.164578
CUP 30.861323
CVE 110.254419
CZK 24.274232
DJF 207.440983
DKK 7.469133
DOP 74.682833
DZD 151.520998
EGP 55.351124
ERN 17.468674
ETB 181.088421
FJD 2.645691
FKP 0.873468
GBP 0.872491
GEL 3.138508
GGP 0.873468
GHS 13.308723
GIP 0.873468
GMD 85.589934
GNF 10126.028236
GTQ 8.923105
GYD 243.716611
HKD 9.061671
HNL 30.593578
HRK 7.535056
HTG 152.525363
HUF 384.021425
IDR 19437.858928
ILS 3.744486
IMP 0.873468
INR 104.745194
IQD 1525.597493
IRR 49057.858566
ISK 148.82132
JEP 0.873468
JMD 186.752078
JOD 0.825704
JPY 181.933909
KES 150.521616
KGS 101.84268
KHR 4663.572474
KMF 493.780761
KPW 1048.120262
KRW 1709.965829
KWD 0.357554
KYD 0.970811
KZT 595.26543
LAK 25263.683987
LBP 104326.769319
LKR 359.467046
LRD 205.609386
LSL 19.780687
LTL 3.438697
LVL 0.704442
LYD 6.33042
MAD 10.786908
MDL 19.751189
MGA 5194.501499
MKD 61.63435
MMK 2445.6481
MNT 4131.893999
MOP 9.335644
MRU 46.347949
MUR 53.745547
MVR 17.946518
MWK 2022.292297
MXN 21.261125
MYR 4.789875
MZN 74.418489
NAD 19.780687
NGN 1691.082209
NIO 42.865886
NOK 11.795012
NPR 167.772899
NZD 2.012281
OMR 0.447779
PAB 1.164888
PEN 3.916481
PGK 4.947009
PHP 69.07816
PKR 326.778058
PLN 4.238873
PYG 8011.265579
QAR 4.240204
RON 5.090026
RSD 117.41628
RUB 89.031619
RWF 1694.937342
SAR 4.370562
SBD 9.577286
SCR 15.828219
SDG 700.501887
SEK 10.920955
SGD 1.510499
SHP 0.873735
SLE 27.823965
SLL 24420.621214
SOS 665.555232
SRD 45.021424
STD 24104.418272
STN 24.497649
SVC 10.193066
SYP 12876.544773
SZL 19.775187
THB 37.066776
TJS 10.688028
TMT 4.076024
TND 3.421757
TOP 2.804025
TRY 49.586224
TTD 7.892276
TWD 36.271887
TZS 2853.216319
UAH 49.109787
UGX 4121.604462
USD 1.164578
UYU 45.505438
UZS 13967.719529
VES 300.002576
VND 30704.105269
VUV 141.895799
WST 3.247554
XAF 655.894056
XAG 0.019829
XAU 0.000277
XCD 3.147331
XCG 2.099508
XDR 0.815722
XOF 655.896872
XPF 119.331742
YER 277.810358
ZAR 19.844134
ZMK 10482.599985
ZMW 26.93853
ZWL 374.993718
  • CMSC

    -0.2100

    23.22

    -0.9%

  • BCC

    -1.2400

    71.81

    -1.73%

  • CMSD

    -0.0800

    23.17

    -0.35%

  • RBGPF

    0.7600

    79.11

    +0.96%

  • NGG

    -0.0800

    75.33

    -0.11%

  • JRI

    -0.0700

    13.72

    -0.51%

  • SCS

    -0.0200

    16.12

    -0.12%

  • RIO

    -0.0400

    73.02

    -0.05%

  • BCE

    -0.2100

    23.34

    -0.9%

  • GSK

    0.0600

    48.47

    +0.12%

  • AZN

    1.1000

    91.28

    +1.21%

  • RYCEF

    0.2100

    14.83

    +1.42%

  • RELX

    -0.8400

    39.48

    -2.13%

  • BTI

    0.4000

    57.41

    +0.7%

  • VOD

    0.0300

    12.5

    +0.24%

  • BP

    -0.0500

    35.78

    -0.14%

Six young people sue 32 European states over climate change
Six young people sue 32 European states over climate change / Photo: CARLOS COSTA - AFP

Six young people sue 32 European states over climate change

Six Portuguese youths are taking 32 nations to the European Court of Human Rights this month for not doing enough to stop global warming, the latest bid to secure climate justice through the courts.

Text size:

The move was sparked by the massive wildfires that struck Portugal in 2017, killing over 100 people and charring swathes of the country.

Aged 11 to 24, the young people say they are suffering from anxiety over their health and "having to live with a climate that is getting hotter and hotter" with more natural disasters.

Some claim allergies and breathing problems both during the fires and after, conditions at risk of persisting if the planet keeps warming.

Underscoring the potential impact of the case in terms of forcing countries to act, the Strasbourg-based court's Grand Chamber will examine the arguments on September 27, something that is reserved for exceptional cases.

The youths argue that excessive carbon emissions are infringing in particular the right to life and the right to the respect of private and family life.

"This is truly a David and Goliath case," said Gearoid O Cuinn, director of the Global Legal Action Network (GLAN), which is supporting the youths' case.

"Never before have so many countries had to defend themselves in front of any court anywhere in the world," he said.

Activists are increasingly turning to courts to force greater efforts by governments to tackle climate change, amid warnings the world is falling short of the 2015 Paris Agreement goals for limiting warming to 1.5 degrees Celsius above mid-19th century levels.

In August, a court in the US state of Montana ruled in favour of a group of youths who accused it of violating their rights to a clean environment.

- 'Game changer' -

An ECHR ruling, expected in several months, in favour of the plaintiffs would be binding on the 46 member states of the Council of Europe and potentially constitute legal jurisprudence on climate cases.

Nations would have to "rapidly accelerate their climate mitigation efforts", said Gerry Liston, a GLAN lawyer assisting the youths.

"In legal terms, it would be a game changer."

But first, the court will rule on the admissibility of the case, since the Portuguese youths filed directly to the ECHR without first seeking recourse in domestic courts.

They argue that trying to file separate cases in all 32 countries would be an "excessive and disproportionate burden" on an issue requiring urgent attention.

An ECHR source confirmed that it was a "unique case" in terms of the number of nations targeted by a single complaint.

The court has not previously ruled on member obligations with regards to climate change.

The youths say governments are contributing to warmer temperatures with carbon emissions that are provoking heat waves and wildfires in their country in particular.

"Governments around the world have the power to stop this, and Europe's governments are choosing not to stop this," said Catarina dos Santos Mota, one of the young Portuguese.

Two other climate cases involving France and Switzerland were examined by the ECHR in March, though no rulings have yet been issued.

According to the UN Environment Programme, the number of legal cases worldwide linked to climate challenges doubled between 2017 and 2022.

Y.Sharma--DT