Dubai Telegraph - Mistrust undermines Ivory Coast's universal healthcare dream

EUR -
AED 4.254885
AFN 73.567814
ALL 94.598007
AMD 426.600616
ANG 2.074325
AOA 1063.000721
ARS 1664.575106
AUD 1.64142
AWG 2.085444
AZN 1.968596
BAM 1.952413
BBD 2.33465
BDT 142.294364
BGN 1.95902
BHD 0.436905
BIF 3465.31278
BMD 1.15858
BND 1.485024
BOB 8.039053
BRL 5.8981
BSD 1.159189
BTN 109.555933
BWP 15.532054
BYN 3.209232
BYR 22708.168
BZD 2.331355
CAD 1.623756
CDF 2687.90574
CHF 0.919142
CLF 0.026075
CLP 1026.223672
CNY 7.829047
CNH 7.832916
COP 3979.7223
CRC 527.98401
CUC 1.15858
CUP 30.70237
CVE 110.470693
CZK 24.100839
DJF 205.902683
DKK 7.456783
DOP 67.892723
DZD 153.950921
EGP 57.822639
ERN 17.3787
ETB 183.490132
FJD 2.587921
FKP 0.86213
GBP 0.864567
GEL 3.064443
GGP 0.86213
GHS 13.089289
GIP 0.86213
GMD 84.575974
GNF 10169.43481
GTQ 8.835747
GYD 242.479327
HKD 9.07799
HNL 30.930838
HRK 7.532973
HTG 151.387361
HUF 348.326662
IDR 20563.172988
ILS 3.381634
IMP 0.86213
INR 109.265098
IQD 1517.7398
IRR 1593047.499933
ISK 144.046287
JEP 0.86213
JMD 183.331941
JOD 0.821455
JPY 185.677505
KES 150.059488
KGS 101.317545
KHR 4648.794215
KMF 492.396282
KPW 1042.722405
KRW 1751.616548
KWD 0.356956
KYD 0.966024
KZT 565.294402
LAK 25523.517173
LBP 103750.839063
LKR 388.339628
LRD 211.03515
LSL 18.763038
LTL 3.420985
LVL 0.700814
LYD 7.38597
MAD 10.711092
MDL 20.227907
MGA 4866.035941
MKD 61.505117
MMK 2432.37726
MNT 4144.618153
MOP 9.352574
MRU 46.435939
MUR 54.604154
MVR 17.91193
MWK 2011.295178
MXN 19.943541
MYR 4.709401
MZN 74.035701
NAD 18.771217
NGN 1574.648845
NIO 42.415729
NOK 10.995446
NPR 175.288382
NZD 1.99468
OMR 0.445472
PAB 1.159189
PEN 3.953666
PGK 5.08356
PHP 69.946961
PKR 322.430713
PLN 4.226117
PYG 7073.727914
QAR 4.217813
RON 5.221762
RSD 117.098902
RUB 84.543374
RWF 1723.96704
SAR 4.34687
SBD 9.339805
SCR 16.353499
SDG 695.726506
SEK 10.894244
SGD 1.485334
SHP 0.864997
SLE 28.675193
SLL 24294.847556
SOS 662.137191
SRD 43.252139
STD 23980.266836
STN 24.793612
SVC 10.142492
SYP 128.060278
SZL 18.765381
THB 37.693822
TJS 10.745558
TMT 4.066616
TND 3.373496
TOP 2.789583
TRY 53.662906
TTD 7.874339
TWD 36.563049
TZS 3041.275941
UAH 51.914682
UGX 4288.559853
USD 1.15858
UYU 46.799213
UZS 13908.752735
VES 690.555849
VND 30500.77708
VUV 138.163938
WST 3.174178
XAF 654.820963
XAG 0.016607
XAU 0.000268
XCD 3.131121
XCG 2.089158
XDR 0.81529
XOF 654.597907
XPF 119.331742
YER 276.466182
ZAR 18.803829
ZMK 10428.609136
ZMW 20.488455
ZWL 373.062287
  • NGG

    -0.8900

    81.39

    -1.09%

  • CMSC

    0.0000

    22.365

    0%

  • RELX

    -0.0200

    32.78

    -0.06%

  • VOD

    -0.3200

    14.57

    -2.2%

  • RIO

    -1.7800

    103.96

    -1.71%

  • BCE

    -0.3350

    23.485

    -1.43%

  • CMSD

    0.0000

    22.26

    0%

  • RBGPF

    0.0000

    62.87

    0%

  • JRI

    -0.0950

    12.715

    -0.75%

  • GSK

    0.0800

    52.3

    +0.15%

  • AZN

    -0.0100

    178.7

    -0.01%

  • BP

    -0.3650

    40.785

    -0.89%

  • RYCEF

    0.3500

    18.98

    +1.84%

  • BCC

    1.4200

    72.98

    +1.95%

  • BTI

    -1.4150

    59.965

    -2.36%

Mistrust undermines Ivory Coast's universal healthcare dream
Mistrust undermines Ivory Coast's universal healthcare dream / Photo: Issouf SANOGO - AFP

Mistrust undermines Ivory Coast's universal healthcare dream

As patients enter a major Abidjan hospital, a large sign informs them that Ivory Coast's universal health insurance will cover some of their medical expenses.

Text size:

But although the healthcare coverage has been available for six years, many Ivorians still have not signed up for it -- and those that have often don't bother trying to use it.

Disillusionment and a lack of confidence in accessing the promised benefits have hampered government efforts to roll the system out.

Universal health coverage, known by its French acronym CMU, was first touted in Ivory Coast by President Alassane Ouattara, who in October will seek a fourth term in office.

The insurance scheme covers 70 percent of the costs of medical consultations and some medications for a monthly charge of 1,000 CFA francs ($1.80). The poorest receive full coverage.

But mistrust, fuelled by tales of health cards not working and a lack of information, have done nothing to encourage enrolment.

Medicines are often unavailable in pharmacies, with people complaining that replacement drugs are not covered by the CMU.

"Every time I tried, it didn't cover my medicines," Felix, who is in his 50s, said, adding he had to fork out 12,000 CFA francs a month on private health insurance.

Others share the opinion of the civil servant, who did not want his full name published, that universal health coverage "is useless".

In mid-July, authorities patted themselves on the back when enrolment hit 20 million, or two-thirds of the population.

Two years ago, the government even made enrolment compulsory for getting a passport, school and university registration and applying for a driver's licence.

It led to a surge in membership, which in 2022 was still under four million -- a "dazzling evolution", said Ahmed Diomande, deputy director general of the National Health Insurance Fund (CNAM).

However, less than four percent of those signed up to the CMU have used their insurance card this year, official figures show.

- 'A waste' -

Marie Djedje said she joined the CMU but later gave up out of disappointment.

"A card that doesn't work and I'm going to pay 1,000 francs. It's a waste!" she grumbled, leaving the hospital in Abidjan's Cocody neighbourhood.

Leaning on his crutch, Curtis Djibran, in his 40s, grimaced as he hobbled out after surgery on his foot following a road accident.

He told AFP he had signed up for universal health coverage but had not paid his monthly premium, forcing him to dip into savings to pay his health costs.

Under a recent push to drive up membership, mobile enrolment centres criss-crossed the country, with thousands of health agents, media, local deputies and traditional chiefs also spreading the word.

The health stakes are high.

Life expectancy at birth in the west African country is 60 years for men and 64 for women, according to the United Nations Population Fund.

While higher than at the turn of the century, Ivory Coast, the world's top cocoa grower and a regional economic powerhouse, trails Senegal and Cameroon.

"Many people enrol but don't use their card," Wilfried Abo, a gastroenterologist at the Cocody hospital, said.

"Most patients complain that many treatments and medications are not covered," he said, highlighting a lack of information.

Several hundred reference medicines -- original versions already on the market -- are covered by the scheme under "an evolving basket of care", the CNAM's Diomande said.

Studies on widening coverage to more illnesses such as some cancers are under way, he added.

- Poverty and perception -

Social anthropologist Firmin Kra said CMU services were "not adapted to the needs".

"A broad effort must be carried out with the various stakeholders to collect health data and map health needs," he said.

Universal health coverage "was not requested by the population, it was politicians who created the offer", the researcher added.

That explains why "the citizen perceives it as a tool used by the government to enrich itself", he said.

For big families, a monthly payment of 1,000 CFA francs is also a burden.

But the biggest challenge relates to farmers and workers in the informal economy, who desperately need low-cost health insurance.

More than 88 percent of Ivory Coast's jobs have no or little formal structure, according to the African Development Bank.

Most informal sector and farm workers cannot afford to keep up their monthly health coverage premiums.

According to CNAM, less than 10 percent of those in the informal sector -- which includes jobs such as street hawkers, market vendors or small-scale construction workers -- have managed to pay the monthly fee at least once.

The government has stepped up efforts to help by making the CMU free for four months this year.

It also struck an accord with the Coffee and Cocoa Council to assume the payments for 700,000 producers.

But the goal of ensuring all obtain the health services they need without financial hardship is still not a reality for many Ivorians.

H.Hajar--DT