Dubai Telegraph - Russian captain found guilty in fatal North Sea crash

EUR -
AED 4.216125
AFN 74.621719
ALL 91.702089
AMD 416.711307
ANG 2.055386
AOA 1052.739855
ARS 1733.529937
AUD 1.611486
AWG 2.069317
AZN 1.94802
BAM 1.955853
BBD 2.311953
BDT 140.963825
BGN 1.932634
BHD 0.43271
BIF 3453.378665
BMD 1.148026
BND 1.464633
BOB 11.679317
BRL 5.885123
BSD 1.147826
BTN 110.061986
BWP 15.566355
BYN 3.489479
BYR 22501.312563
BZD 2.308653
CAD 1.605302
CDF 2653.089103
CHF 0.946961
CLF 0.027903
CLP 1101.772158
CNY 7.700443
CNH 7.687671
COP 3638.014511
CRC 513.511697
CUC 1.148026
CUP 30.422693
CVE 110.267992
CZK 24.315711
DJF 204.404656
DKK 7.475481
DOP 67.991549
DZD 153.69284
EGP 59.843733
ERN 17.220392
ETB 187.497071
FJD 2.544489
FKP 0.853761
GBP 0.859166
GEL 2.990619
GGP 0.853761
GHS 13.212359
GIP 0.853761
GMD 84.368659
GNF 10073.9293
GTQ 8.758238
GYD 240.116515
HKD 9.006093
HNL 30.808702
HRK 7.535187
HTG 150.023417
HUF 362.498439
IDR 20371.724053
ILS 3.482979
IMP 0.853761
INR 109.926431
IQD 1503.734254
IRR 1578076.747429
ISK 139.405036
JEP 0.853761
JMD 181.144126
JOD 0.813942
JPY 180.034032
KES 148.841865
KGS 100.395388
KHR 4675.106495
KMF 491.355358
KPW 1033.223901
KRW 1589.413473
KWD 0.354165
KYD 0.956622
KZT 511.321648
LAK 25709.585645
LBP 102792.341533
LKR 380.718672
LRD 199.155404
LSL 18.699326
LTL 3.389823
LVL 0.694429
LYD 7.291166
MAD 10.933797
MDL 20.151459
MGA 4985.113557
MKD 61.526669
MMK 2410.470116
MNT 4129.27924
MOP 9.275911
MRU 45.984047
MUR 54.714996
MVR 17.737289
MWK 1990.445341
MXN 19.690933
MYR 4.683681
MZN 73.35324
NAD 18.699326
NGN 1528.126437
NIO 42.240962
NOK 10.811898
NPR 176.098011
NZD 2.00755
OMR 0.441414
PAB 1.147831
PEN 3.875205
PGK 5.107116
PHP 71.941631
PKR 318.162548
PLN 4.356506
PYG 6790.154675
QAR 4.184214
RON 5.261981
RSD 117.387978
RUB 97.016735
RWF 1693.738582
SAR 4.263076
SBD 9.184797
SCR 15.789434
SDG 690.527373
SEK 11.269088
SGD 1.464755
SHP 0.857536
SLE 28.287533
SLL 24073.525056
SOS 656.014944
SRD 43.333965
STD 23761.823474
STN 24.500558
SVC 10.044229
SYP 14926.63631
SZL 18.692426
THB 38.194523
TJS 10.589187
TMT 4.018092
TND 3.343624
TOP 2.764171
TRY 56.004889
TTD 7.793178
TWD 36.501605
TZS 3041.245294
UAH 51.294568
UGX 4511.122407
USD 1.148026
UYU 46.151252
UZS 13516.307891
VES 970.604392
VND 29853.272035
VUV 135.819625
WST 3.148936
XAF 655.957
XAG 0.017427
XAU 0.000264
XCD 3.102598
XCG 2.068747
XDR 0.811714
XOF 655.957
XPF 119.331742
YER 271.680336
ZAR 18.658806
ZMK 10333.615177
ZMW 22.527513
ZWL 369.663952
SSP 6495.73372
MXV 2.232544
  • CMSD

    0.1600

    20.45

    +0.78%

  • CMSC

    0.1900

    20.67

    +0.92%

  • GSK

    0.7700

    51.06

    +1.51%

  • BTI

    -0.0700

    56.02

    -0.12%

  • RIO

    2.2500

    98.04

    +2.29%

  • RBGPF

    0.0000

    69.99

    0%

  • NGG

    1.5700

    77.6

    +2.02%

  • BCE

    -0.2200

    22.28

    -0.99%

  • BCC

    0.2200

    75.53

    +0.29%

  • RELX

    0.1100

    34.38

    +0.32%

  • JRI

    0.1100

    11.61

    +0.95%

  • BP

    0.0400

    45.42

    +0.09%

  • AZN

    3.2500

    166.14

    +1.96%

  • VOD

    0.0600

    17.52

    +0.34%

  • RYCEF

    0.5200

    19.81

    +2.62%

Russian captain found guilty in fatal North Sea crash
Russian captain found guilty in fatal North Sea crash / Photo: Paul ELLIS - AFP

Russian captain found guilty in fatal North Sea crash

The Russian captain of a cargo ship that hit an anchored oil tanker in the North Sea last year was on Monday found guilty by a UK court of killing a crew member.

Text size:

After eight hours of deliberation, the jury convicted Vladimir Motin of the manslaughter by gross negligence of Filipino sailor Mark Angelo Pernia.

The seaman, 38, who was married with a young child, was lost at sea following the crash in which Motin's cargo ship, the Solong, collided with the oil-laden Stena Immaculate, triggering a fiery blaze off the eastern UK coast.

Pernia's body has never been recovered.

Motin, from Saint Petersburg, showed no emotion as he was convicted by a jury at London's Old Bailey court.

He was remanded in custody and will be sentenced on Thursday.

Speaking after the verdict, investigating officer Craig Nicholson described the crash as a "senseless tragedy".

"It's a miracle that there weren't more fatalities or serious injuries," he said.

Prosecutor Tom Little told the court Pernia's wife -- who was seven months pregnant with their second child at the time of his death -- lived in a remote area of the Philippines.

She would need to make arrangements to travel somewhere with good internet access to watch the sentencing remotely.

"This was a tragic, and entirely avoidable death of a member of crew caused by truly, exceptionally bad negligence," said prosecutor Michael Gregory.

"It is with great sadness for his family that his body has never been found," he added.

- 'Collision course' -

The collision at speed in March set both vessels ablaze and triggered a massive offshore rescue operation.

Motin's defence lawyer, James Leonard, had previously told the trial that the captain had attempted to take the Portuguese-flagged Solong out of autopilot and change course manually to avoid crashing into the Stena Immaculate, which had been chartered by the US military.

"That attempt, however, was not successful and the Solong did not change course at all," he said.

Motin told the court he had made a "mistake" and pressed the wrong button.

The jury was told Motin was a "highly trained" sailor who had captained the Solong for 15 years.

But the prosecution insisted that he "did nothing to avoid the collision".

"He could, and should, have acted differently" when his ship was on "an obvious collision course" with the tanker, Little told the trial.

The CPS said the Solong's black box showed no course or speed adjustments before the collision.

It added that Motin had disabled the alarm system, "leaving him alone to be on watch as the eyes and ears of the ship".

WhatsApp messages sent to Motin by his wife had "undermined his credibility", the CPS noted.

She had told him to "think of an alibi and advised him to say he had not seen the other vessel on the control devices".

- 'Catastrophic' -

Audio recordings from the Solong's bridge control room were played to jurors, accompanied by a visual reconstruction of the ship's trajectory towards the Stena Immaculate.

An hour before the collision, men could be heard speaking calmly in Russian about the price of cigarettes. Then a Russian folksong is heard, an apparent phone ringtone which went unanswered.

As the Solong approached the anchored oil tanker, no conversation could be heard in the control room at all. The ensuing sound of the collision's initial impact was so loud that jurors winced after being warned to decrease the volume on their listening devices.

The jury saw phone footage recorded by Joesen Mariposila, the Solong's third-in-command, showing fire at the ship's other end.

He was heard saying "Lord help us" five times as dark smoke began to fill the air.

Malcolm McHaffie, head of the Crown Prosecution Service's special crime division, said the case underlined "the gravity of a captain's duty of care while out at sea".

"If that duty of care is breached, the consequences can be catastrophic."

A.El-Ahbaby--DT